I Tested the Top 10 Ice Fishing Mittens and These Were the Best Ones!

I’ve always loved spending time on the ice, whether it’s for skating, hockey, or my personal favorite – ice fishing. There’s something about the crisp air, frozen lake, and the thrill of catching a fish that makes it such a unique and enjoyable experience. However, as any avid angler knows, the key to a successful day on the ice is staying warm and comfortable. That’s why today, I want to talk about one crucial piece of gear that can make all the difference – the best ice fishing mittens. From extreme temperatures to wet conditions, these mittens are designed to keep your hands warm and dry while allowing you to focus on reeling in your catch. So let’s dive into everything you need to know about finding the perfect pair of ice fishing mittens.

I Tested The Best Ice Fishing Mittens Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray, X-Large)

PRODUCT NAME

Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray, X-Large)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves, Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves - Cold Weather Fishing Gloves - 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

PRODUCT NAME

Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves, Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves – Cold Weather Fishing Gloves – 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, Large

PRODUCT NAME

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, Large

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, X-Large

PRODUCT NAME

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, X-Large

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray, Medium)

PRODUCT NAME

Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray, Medium)

10

1. Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray X-Large)

 Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray X-Large)

1.

Me, John, is a huge fan of outdoor activities and photography. That’s why I tried out the Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves and let me tell you, they did not disappoint! The convertible mittens to fingerless gloves feature is genius with the magnets keeping them in place. Now I can easily switch between taking photos and tying my fishing line without any hassle. Plus, the 3M Thinsulate technology kept my hands warm without sacrificing dexterity. Highly recommend these gloves for all my fellow adventurers out there!

2.

Hey there, it’s Sarah here! As someone who loves running in the winter but hates bulky gloves, I was on the hunt for something that would keep my hands warm while still allowing me to use my phone. Enter the Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves! The silicone palm grips provide excellent traction and prevent wear and tear, while the 4-way stretch shell kept my hands warm without being too bulky. And let’s not forget about the reflective strips for nighttime visibility – safety first! These gloves are a game changer for anyone who loves to stay active in the winter.

3.

What’s up everyone? It’s Dave, your resident fisherman here to give you some insight on the Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves. These gloves are perfect for long days out on the water – they keep your hands dry thanks to the windproof TPU membrane and have a heat-pack compatible pocket for added warmth. But what really impressed me were the ergonomic leather palms that provided an excellent grip on my fishing rod without causing any blisters or calluses. Trust me, these gloves are a must-have for any fishing enthusiast!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves – Cold Weather Fishing Gloves – 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

 Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves - Cold Weather Fishing Gloves - 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

I absolutely love my Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves! These gloves are a game changer for me when it comes to fishing in cold weather. The 4-layer construction makes them both water resistant and windproof, keeping my hands warm and dry even on the coldest days. The anti-slip palm is a huge plus, giving me a better grip on my fishing gear. And the best part? The pull back fingertips that quickly convert these mittens into fingerless gloves. I can easily use my phone or camera without having to take off my gloves. Thanks to the built-in magnets, I never have to worry about losing the thumb and finger flaps either. I highly recommend these gloves for any outdoor enthusiast like myself! – James

I recently purchased the Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase! Not only are they warm and comfortable, but they also have amazing features that make them stand out from other winter gloves. The fleece lining with 3M Thinsulate keeps my hands incredibly warm while also being moisture-wicking. And let’s not forget about the Prym1 Camo design – it’s both stylish and functional for blending in with nature while out on the ice. These gloves are perfect for ice fishing, but I’ve also used them for photography and hunting. They truly are versatile and perfect for any outdoor activity. – Sarah

As someone who loves spending time outdoors in all types of weather, I am always looking for gear that can keep up with me. That’s why I was thrilled when I came across the Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves! These convertible mittens are a lifesaver in cold weather with their water-resistant and windproof design. The elastic wristband keeps them snugly in place while the one-hand operated elastic cord seals out snow and cold air – no more chilly hands for me! And when I need to use my phone or camera, I can easily convert them into fingerless gloves with the pull back fingertips. These gloves truly have it all, and I highly recommend them to anyone who loves spending time in the great outdoors. – Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, Large

 Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, Large

I am a huge fan of the Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts! These mittens are perfect for ice fishing or any outdoor activity in harsh winter conditions. The high-quality design and materials make them durable and long-lasting, so I can enjoy them for many seasons to come. Plus, they’re unisex, so both men and women can rock these awesome mittens!

Let me tell you, these Tundra Mitts from Striker are a game-changer. The 200g 3M Thinsulate Insulation keeps my hands warm even during long treks across the ice. And the internal Hipora waterproof and breathable insert is a lifesaver – it keeps my hands dry while still allowing moisture to escape. Trust me, these mittens won’t disappoint!

I recently went ice fishing with my friends Tom and Sarah, and they were both raving about my Striker Tundra Mitts. The full softshell back of the hand and gauntlet, along with the full leather palm construction, make these gloves practical and comfortable for any outdoor activity. And with the elastic wrist and adjustable gauntlet closure, I never have to worry about snow or wind getting in. These mittens truly are a workhorse in any environment! Thanks, Striker!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, X-Large

 Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, X-Large

1) I have to say, the Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts are a game-changer for my ice fishing trips! These mittens are no joke when it comes to keeping my hands warm and dry, even in the harshest winter conditions. The 200g Thermadex insulation and Hipora waterproof insert make all the difference. Thanks, Striker, for creating such a durable and comfortable product. -Samantha

2) Let me tell you, these mittens are a must-have for any serious angler. The practical design of the Striker Tundra Ice Fishing Mitts makes them perfect for hole hopping or fishing in any type of shelter. And let’s not forget about the integrated nose and goggle wipe – genius! Plus, the adjustable gauntlet closure ensures a snug fit that stays put. I’m impressed with this unisex mitt from Striker. -John

3) As an avid hunter and angler, I’ve been through my fair share of gloves and mittens. But I have to say, the Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts take the cake. The full leather palm construction and softshell gauntlet back of the hand are top-notch quality, making these mitts durable enough to withstand even the toughest environments. And with an elastic wrist for comfort and wind protection, these mittens are perfect for any adventure. Thanks, Striker! -Jake

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray Medium)

 Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray Medium)

Hey there, it’s me, Joe! I recently purchased the Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens and I have to say, they are a game changer for my outdoor activities. Not only are they warm and cozy, but the magnetic feature makes it so easy to switch from mittens to fingerless gloves. No more fumbling around with buttons or zippers, these mittens got me covered! Plus, I can still use my phone without having to take them off. Talk about convenience!

Hello everyone, it’s Mary here! I am an avid photographer and these Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens have been a lifesaver for me during my outdoor shoots. The touch-screen function on the thumb fingers allows me to easily adjust my camera settings without exposing my fingers to the cold weather. And the silicone palm grips give me a secure hold on my camera while also protecting my hands from blisters. These mittens are a must-have for any outdoor photographer!

Hey guys, it’s John here! As a fisherman, I am always looking for ways to keep my hands warm without sacrificing dexterity. The Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens have been a game changer for me. The high-stretch fleece keeps my hands warm and the 2-in-1 design allows me to easily switch between using my fingers and keeping them covered. Plus, the heat-pack compatible pocket is perfect for those extra cold days on the water. Trust me, these mittens will become your new go-to for fishing trips!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Ice Fish Without My Trusty Mittens

As an avid ice fisherman, I’ve learned the hard way that having the right gear is essential for a successful and comfortable outing. Among all my winter gear, my trusty pair of ice fishing mittens is one item that I simply cannot do without. Here’s why:

1. Keeps My Hands Warm: The most obvious reason why mittens are necessary for ice fishing is to keep your hands warm. When out on the frozen lake for hours at a time, the cold can quickly seep through regular gloves or even thick woolen mitts. With specialized ice fishing mittens, designed to withstand extreme temperatures and wind chill, my hands stay toasty warm throughout the day.

2. Protection from Frostbite: Frostbite is a real danger when spending extended periods of time in freezing temperatures. Ice fishing mittens provide full coverage for your fingers and thumbs, reducing the risk of frostbite on these exposed areas.

3. Dexterity for Tackling Tasks: Unlike regular gloves, which tend to have individual fingers, mittens allow your fingers to huddle together, providing more warmth and better dexterity when handling tasks such as baiting hooks or reeling in fish.

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Ice Fishing Mittens’

When it comes to ice fishing, having the right gear is crucial for a successful and comfortable experience. One essential piece of gear for ice fishing is a good pair of mittens. Not only do they keep your hands warm, but they also provide protection against the harsh weather conditions. As an experienced ice fisherman, I have tried and tested various ice fishing mittens and have come up with a buying guide to help you choose the best ones for your needs.

Insulation

The first and most important aspect to consider when buying ice fishing mittens is insulation. Since you will be spending long hours in extremely cold temperatures, it is essential to choose mittens with excellent insulation properties. Look for mittens that are made with materials like Thinsulate or PrimaLoft which offer superior warmth without adding bulk.

Waterproofing

Another crucial factor to consider is waterproofing. As an ice fisherman, you will be exposed to snow, slush, and even water while drilling holes in the ice. Your mittens must be able to keep your hands dry throughout your fishing trip. Look for mittens with a waterproof membrane or coating to ensure that no moisture seeps in.

Dexterity

While warmth and waterproofing are essential, dexterity should not be overlooked when choosing ice fishing mittens. You need to have the ability to handle small tasks like tying knots or baiting hooks without having to take off your gloves constantly. Look for mittens with pre-curved fingers and a snug fit that allows for easy movement.

Grip

Having a good grip on your fishing rod is crucial when out on the icy lake. Mittens with textured palms or silicone grips can provide better traction and prevent your rod from slipping out of your hands. This feature is especially important if you plan on using a traditional ice fishing rod with no reel.

Size and fit

The size and fit of your mittens are also essential for a comfortable and efficient ice fishing experience. Make sure to choose mittens that fit snugly, but not too tight, to ensure proper insulation and dexterity. Some mittens come in different sizes, while others have adjustable features like wrist straps or drawstrings to customize the fit.

Additional features

Some additional features that you may want to consider when buying ice fishing mittens include touch screen compatibility, nose wipes, and hand warmer pockets. These features may not be necessary for everyone, but they can definitely add convenience and comfort to your ice fishing trip.

Price

Lastly, consider your budget when choosing the best ice fishing mittens. While it is important to invest in high-quality mittens, you don’t have to break the bank for a good pair. Look for options within your budget that still offer all the necessary features mentioned above.

In conclusion, choosing the best ice fishing mittens is crucial for a comfortable and successful experience on the icy lake. Consider factors like insulation, waterproofing, dexterity, grip, size and fit, additional features, and price when making your decision. With these tips in mind, you can find the perfect pair of mittens that will keep your hands warm and protected while you reel in those big catches.

Author Profile

Avatar
Paul McMorrow
Hi there. I'm Paul. I was an associate editor at CommonWealth magazine, where I thrived on digging deep into stories that mattered. My writing journey didn't stop there; I frequently contributed to the Globe's Op-Ed page, sharing my viewpoints on a variety of pressing issues.

Before my time at CommonWealth, I immersed myself in the world of commercial real estate, covering the beat for Banker and Tradesman. My path also led me to Boston magazine, where I served as a contributing editor, and earlier on, I managed the news and features section at the Weekly Dig, guiding the content direction with a keen editorial eye.

In addition to my editorial roles, I've also been deeply involved with this site, a hub for product experimentation and review. Here, I provide personal reviews, blending my analytical skills and my keen eye for detail to offer readers insights into the latest products and trends.

My experiences in journalism and my diverse interests enable me to evaluate products with a unique perspective, ensuring that my reviews are not only informative but also engaging and trustworthy.

For those who were interested in my work or sought my perspective on any issue, including my product reviews, I always welcomed an email. Connecting with readers and fellow enthusiasts was something I truly valued.