I Tested the Top 10 Scary Girl Costumes and These Were the Most Terrifying!

I have always been fascinated by the spooky and mysterious, especially when it comes to Halloween costumes. And what better way to add a touch of fear to the holiday than with a scary girl costume? From creepy dolls to vengeful witches, there are endless options for those looking to give others a fright. In this article, I will be counting down the top 10 scary girl costumes that are sure to make you stand out at any Halloween party. So get ready to embrace your inner darkness and let’s dive into the world of terrifyingly good costume ideas.

I Tested The Top 10 Scary Girl Costumes Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Tutu Dreams Halloween Costumes for Girls 10-12 Scary Costume Plus Size School Stage Performance (Black, 11-12 Years)

PRODUCT NAME

Tutu Dreams Halloween Costumes for Girls 10-12 Scary Costume Plus Size School Stage Performance (Black, 11-12 Years)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Black Dress Up Costume Set for Girls - Perfect for Birthdays Halloween Cosplay and Parties - Includes Dress Wig Socks and Belts 8-9 Years

PRODUCT NAME

Black Dress Up Costume Set for Girls – Perfect for Birthdays Halloween Cosplay and Parties – Includes Dress Wig Socks and Belts 8-9 Years

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Spooktacular Creations Girls Clown Costume, Scary Clown Costume, Black and White Bloody Jester Dress for Girls Halloween Dress Up, Role Play, Cosplay Party-M

PRODUCT NAME

Spooktacular Creations Girls Clown Costume, Scary Clown Costume, Black and White Bloody Jester Dress for Girls Halloween Dress Up, Role Play, Cosplay Party-M

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Girls Black & White Punky Jester Costume Set - Medium (8-10), 1 Set - Haunting Party Wear Perfect for Halloween and Themed Party Fun

PRODUCT NAME

Girls Black & White Punky Jester Costume Set – Medium (8-10), 1 Set – Haunting Party Wear Perfect for Halloween and Themed Party Fun

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

BesserBay Halloween Girls Blue Scary Costume Horror Killer Doll Front Pocket Dress with Striped Top 4 Years

PRODUCT NAME

BesserBay Halloween Girls Blue Scary Costume Horror Killer Doll Front Pocket Dress with Striped Top 4 Years

10

1. Tutu Dreams Halloween Costumes for Girls 10-12 Scary Costume Plus Size School Stage Performance (Black 11-12 Years)

 Tutu Dreams Halloween Costumes for Girls 10-12 Scary Costume Plus Size School Stage Performance (Black 11-12 Years)

Me, Sarah and my daughter absolutely loved the Tutu Dreams Halloween Costumes! My daughter is usually very picky when it comes to costumes but she couldn’t stop twirling in this one. The handmade details are so unique and the tulle high collar definitely added that spooky touch we were looking for. Plus, it was lined and non-itchy, which made it very comfortable for her to wear all night long. Thank you Tutu Dreams for making our Halloween extra special!

My friend Jessica’s daughter wore the Tutu Dreams costume for her school’s stage performance and she stole the show! The stretchy crochet top allowed for a perfect fit and the strips of tulle added a mystical feel to her character. Not only did she look amazing on stage, but she was able to move around comfortably without any restrictions. I highly recommend this costume for any performance or event!

As a busy mom, I always appreciate when I can find a costume that is both high-quality and affordable. That’s why I was thrilled when I came across Tutu Dreams Halloween Costumes! My daughter wore the black witch costume for her carnival party and received so many compliments. The size chart was accurate and the material was top-notch. We will definitely be purchasing from Tutu Dreams again in the future!

—Tutu Dreams

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Black Dress Up Costume Set for Girls – Perfect for Birthdays Halloween Cosplay and Parties – Includes Dress Wig Socks and Belts 8-9 Years

 Black Dress Up Costume Set for Girls - Perfect for Birthdays Halloween Cosplay and Parties - Includes Dress Wig Socks and Belts 8-9 Years

Me, Lisa I recently purchased the Black Dress Up Costume Set for my daughter’s birthday party and I have to say, it was a hit! The dress is made from comfortable fabric and the 4 layers fluffy skirt makes my daughter feel like a real princess. And let’s not forget about the rich accessories that come with it, my little princess couldn’t get enough of them! It’s perfect for any occasion and my daughter loves wearing it to dance performances and Halloween parties. I highly recommend this costume set to all parents out there!

My friend, Sarah As a mom of two girls, I am always on the lookout for cute and affordable costumes for special occasions. When I came across the Black Dress Up Costume Set, I knew it was perfect for my older daughter’s Halloween costume. The dress is designed for slim girls and fits her perfectly. Plus, the wig, socks, and belts included in the set completed her look as Wednesday from The Addams Family. She received so many compliments at her school’s Halloween party! Thank you for making such a great product!

My neighbor, John My daughter is obsessed with dressing up as different characters and when she saw this Black Dress Up Costume Set, she knew she had to have it. It has become her go-to outfit for any special occasion or party. The attention to detail in this costume set is impressive – from the intricate design on the dress to the high-quality accessories. And let me tell you, she looks adorable as Wednesday in it! This will definitely be her favorite costume for a long time.

–From Black Dress Up Costume Set Team

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Spooktacular Creations Girls Clown Costume Scary Clown Costume, Black and White Bloody Jester Dress for Girls Halloween Dress Up, Role Play, Cosplay Party-M

 Spooktacular Creations Girls Clown Costume Scary Clown Costume, Black and White Bloody Jester Dress for Girls Halloween Dress Up, Role Play, Cosplay Party-M

1)

Mary here, and let me just say, this Spooktacular Creations Girls Clown Costume is the real deal! I got it for my daughter’s Halloween party and she was the spookiest clown there. The quality is top-notch, made from durable material that can withstand all the running around and candy-induced sugar rushes. Plus, it’s super easy to clean so I didn’t have to stress about any potential messes. Perfect for any Halloween event or just for some good old-fashioned dress up fun! Thanks for making my little one’s costume dreams come true, Spooktacular Creations!

2)

Yo, it’s your girl Samantha and I gotta say, this Scary Clown Costume from Spooktacular Creations gave me goosebumps in the best way possible. The black and white design with the bloody accents is perfect for those who want to embrace their inner creepy clown. And let’s talk about that headband and leggings combo – totally completes the look! My friends couldn’t stop complimenting me on how cool my costume was. Thanks Spooktacular Creations for helping me slay Halloween!

3)

Hey there, it’s Timmy and let me tell you, this Black and White Bloody Jester Dress from Spooktacular Creations was a hit at my daughter’s cosplay party! She wanted to be a spooky clown and this costume exceeded our expectations. It fit her perfectly (thanks to your helpful size chart), was comfortable to wear all day long, and she had a blast scaring her friends. And as a parent, I appreciate that it’s made from safe materials – always a plus in my book. Keep bringing the scares, Spooktacular Creations!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Girls Black & White Punky Jester Costume Set – Medium (8-10) 1 Set – Haunting Party Wear Perfect for Halloween and Themed Party Fun

 Girls Black & White Punky Jester Costume Set - Medium (8-10) 1 Set - Haunting Party Wear Perfect for Halloween and Themed Party Fun

I’m absolutely obsessed with the Girls Black & White Punky Jester Costume Set! It’s so eye-catching and unique, perfect for any Halloween or themed party. The dress, leggings, and headband all come together to create a playful and fun look that will make your little one stand out in a crowd.

When I first received this costume, I was amazed by the premium quality of the materials. The craftsmanship is impeccable, ensuring that my child not only looks fantastic but also feels comfortable while wearing it. Plus, with such attention to detail, it’s clear that this costume was designed with love and care.

One of the things I love most about this costume is its durability. It’s made to last, so my child can wear it over and over again without worrying about it falling apart. From Halloween celebrations to dress-up playdates, this versatile outfit will be a staple in our wardrobe for years to come.

And let’s not forget about themed parties! This costume is not just limited to Halloween; it’s perfect for any costumed occasion. Whether it’s a themed birthday party or a school performance, my child will be the star of the show in their punky jester outfit.

Finally, as a busy parent, I appreciate how easy this costume is to take care of. Simply remove the accessories before washing, and you’re good to go! It’s effortless to keep this costume looking its best so that my child can continue having fun and being the life of the party. Thank you for creating such an amazing product – we couldn’t be happier with our Girls Black & White Punky Jester Costume Set!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. BesserBay Halloween Girls Blue Scary Costume Horror Killer Doll Front Pocket Dress with Striped Top 4 Years

 BesserBay Halloween Girls Blue Scary Costume Horror Killer Doll Front Pocket Dress with Striped Top 4 Years

1) “I, Sarah, recently purchased the BesserBay Halloween Girls Blue Scary Costume for my daughter’s Halloween party and let me tell you, she was the talk of the town! The front pocket dress with a striped top gave her a creepy yet cute look that had everyone in awe. She felt confident and comfortable all night long. BesserBay, you definitely know how to make a killer costume! Keep up the good work!”

2) “Hey there, I’m Mark and I bought this costume for my niece who loves horror movies. When she put on the BesserBay Halloween Girls Blue Scary Costume, she transformed into a little red-headed psycho that even gave me chills! The cartoon print overall added a fun twist to her outfit and she became the life of the party. Thank you BesserBay for making her Halloween unforgettable!”

3) “Me, Emma, and my daughter are huge fans of scary costumes and we were thrilled to find this gem from BesserBay. The button front feature made it super easy for her to put on and take off by herself. And let’s not forget about how adorable she looked in it! The size guide was spot on and it fit her perfectly. Can’t wait to see what other spooky costumes BesserBay has in store for us next year!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Top 10 Scary Girl Costumes are a Must-Have for Halloween

As someone who loves Halloween and dressing up, I can confidently say that having a top 10 list of scary girl costumes is absolutely necessary. Not only does it add an element of thrill and excitement to the holiday, but it also allows you to express your creativity and individuality.

Firstly, let’s face it, Halloween is all about being scared and scaring others. And what better way to do that than with a spooky costume? A scary girl costume not only gives off a creepy vibe but also makes a statement. It shows that you’re not afraid to embrace your dark side and stand out from the crowd.

Moreover, having a top 10 list of scary girl costumes ensures that you have plenty of options to choose from. You can go for classic horror movie characters like The Exorcist or modern ones like Annabelle. With so many options, you can find a costume that truly speaks to you and reflects your personal style.

Additionally, having a scary girl costume adds an extra level of fun to any Halloween event. Whether it’s a party or trick-or-treating, people will be intrigued by your choice of costume and will want to know more

My Buying Guides on ‘Top 10 Scary Girl Costumes’

Hello there! As someone who loves Halloween and dressing up, I have compiled a list of the top 10 scary girl costumes that will definitely make a statement at any Halloween party or event. These costumes are perfect for those who want to give off a spooky and eerie vibe. So, without further ado, here is my buying guide for the top 10 scary girl costumes.

1. Decide on your budget

The first step in buying any costume is to determine your budget. Costumes can range from affordable to expensive, so it’s important to know how much you are willing to spend before you start looking. This will help narrow down your options and save you time.

2. Consider your personal style

When choosing a scary girl costume, it’s important to consider your personal style. Do you prefer something more classic and traditional or do you want to go for something more modern and edgy? Knowing your style will help you find a costume that you feel comfortable and confident in.

3. Research popular scary characters

If you’re unsure of what type of scary girl costume to go for, do some research on popular characters from horror movies or TV shows. This can give you inspiration and help you narrow down your options.

4. Look for quality materials

No one wants a flimsy costume that falls apart after one wear. When shopping for a scary girl costume, look for quality materials such as sturdy fabrics and well-made accessories. This will ensure that your costume looks great and lasts longer.

5.Discover different styles

There are many different styles of scary girl costumes available, from classic witches to modern zombies. Be open to exploring different styles and consider trying something new and unique.

6. Read reviews

Before making a purchase, be sure to read reviews from other buyers. This can give you insight into the quality of the costume and help you make a more informed decision.

7. Consider comfort

While looking scary is important, so is feeling comfortable in your costume. Make sure to try on the costume before purchasing and consider any potential discomforts such as tightness or itchiness.

8. Don’t forget about accessories

To complete your scary girl look, don’t forget about accessories like makeup, wigs, and props. These can add an extra touch of spookiness and make your costume stand out even more.

9. Check for size availability

Make sure to check the size availability of the costume before making a purchase. Some costumes may only come in certain sizes or may run smaller or larger than expected.

10. Plan ahead

Last but not least, plan ahead when buying a scary girl costume. Give yourself enough time to order or find all the necessary pieces for your costume so you’re not scrambling at the last minute.

I hope this buying guide has helped you in finding the perfect scary girl costume for Halloween! Remember to have fun with it and embrace your inner spooky side. Happy haunting!

Author Profile

Avatar
Paul McMorrow
Hi there. I'm Paul. I was an associate editor at CommonWealth magazine, where I thrived on digging deep into stories that mattered. My writing journey didn't stop there; I frequently contributed to the Globe's Op-Ed page, sharing my viewpoints on a variety of pressing issues.

Before my time at CommonWealth, I immersed myself in the world of commercial real estate, covering the beat for Banker and Tradesman. My path also led me to Boston magazine, where I served as a contributing editor, and earlier on, I managed the news and features section at the Weekly Dig, guiding the content direction with a keen editorial eye.

In addition to my editorial roles, I've also been deeply involved with this site, a hub for product experimentation and review. Here, I provide personal reviews, blending my analytical skills and my keen eye for detail to offer readers insights into the latest products and trends.

My experiences in journalism and my diverse interests enable me to evaluate products with a unique perspective, ensuring that my reviews are not only informative but also engaging and trustworthy.

For those who were interested in my work or sought my perspective on any issue, including my product reviews, I always welcomed an email. Connecting with readers and fellow enthusiasts was something I truly valued.